Categories > Coding > C# >
[Brutal Opinion] Executer UI
Posted
Hello,
First time ever doing stuff on C# language and winforms so if i could steal few minutes of your time i would like your opinion about the UI the stuff you dont like and you like or any suggestions.
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1024875253056405554/1029688445704093697/unknown.png
Thank you.
Replied
brutal opinion: i need to clean my brain after seeing this 0/10
actual opinion: not the worst ive seen for a first time ui. doesnt seem too skidded either from youtube tutorials but you need to get some better icons and switch to wpf cuz it has better rendering than winforms and is just a lot faster and easier to do things with, it may seem hard at first because you have to do a lot of things in xaml instead of a designer but it has much better support for animations and other things also dont use gradients that start or end with black, they just dont look good and fix the close/minimize button z index so that it doesnt get affected by the gradient 4/10
Cancel
Post
Did I mention I use arch btw?
Replied
Brutal opinion? It's pretty bad, but props to you for actually asking nicely.
Here are the issues in my opinion:
1) The colour scheme is off, colours are too heavy and there's too much contrast
2) The icons don't look really good and their positioning/sizing isn't consistent
3) Close and minimise are not centered in terms of height compared to the window's top
4) The textbox is way too tall (and as a result the whole ui is), along with it being fastcoloredtextbox
In my opinion, you should entirely scrap this UI and make a new one, keeping in mind the issues I pointed out above (and any other issues others might point out). Another important recommendation is to switch to WPF instead of WinForms, as it's much better for UI design.
One thing worth noting is that this is actually sort of creative for being a first attempt at an UI, I'd say overall it's a 5/10.
Cancel
Post
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/995070188628221952/1022545309529808996/mrk0banner5.png
Replied
Brutal opinion: please stop
Cancel
Post
Replied
Brutal opinion: pretty good for a first timer but the gui colors are a bit off putting to me
Cancel
Post
[ ππππ - ππππ ]
"Bound by self-hatred, bound by blood. In the name of Baphomet and Lucifer, in both I should trust them."
π₯° πππΎπΈπ π
Replied
Brutal opinion: 0/10 "Anyone got a plane that doesnt have a parachute??"
Honest opinion: 4/10 You could do a lot better especially with WinForms, + The icons just dont look nice in my opinion.
But hey, not the worst i've seen for first UI's. I've 100% seen way worse.
Cancel
Post
"And it'll be a long time, before you ever see me again"
Replied
@Whoman hey >:( I use winforms!!!! I like winfawrm! Also API thing might be skidded.
Cancel
Post
Added
I'd say for first UI it's alright. Erm 6/10.
Edit: i thought about this. although the functions may (or may not be good) the ui, is @ss. Just completely. Why did you pick the colors like that? if your gonna do a gradient, stick with it, or at least match the colors. I'd say go with white OR remove the gradiant, and still go with white for the accents. Brutally honest, 2.2/10
My friends honest rating of seeing this ui.
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/1001917565062357082/1029925159861239858/unknown.png
Cancel
Post
Replied
you need better icons and get better 1/10
Cancel
Post
Did I mention I use arch btw?
Did I mention I use arch btw?
Replied
i fell asleep while looking at this
Cancel
Post
Users viewing this thread:
( Members: 0, Guests: 1, Total: 1 )
Cancel
Post